AI Risk Management
October 23, 2024
NIST AI RMF vs. Other AI Frameworks
Knowing how the NIST RMF stacks up against other AI frameworks like ISO 42001 or HITRUST AI RMF will help you understand its role. Each framework has its own approach and focus, so understanding the differences can help you choose the best fit for your organization’s needs.
- ISO 42001 helps you set up and maintain an AI Management System (AIMS). Its main goals are to ensure ethical AI use, maintain transparency, and build trust in AI systems.
- HITRUST AI RMF integrates AI risk management within the broader HITRUST Common Security Framework (CSF). It’s designed to ensure that AI systems align with existing HITRUST standards, focusing on comprehensive risk assessment and mitigation across various sectors.
- The EU AI Act sets legal standards for AI in Europe. It categorizes AI systems by risk and requires specific measures to ensure safety and transparency.
In this section, we’ll compare the NIST AI RMF with other popular AI frameworks and highlight key distinctions and similarities to guide you in deciding which framework aligns with your goals.
| Parameters | NIST AI RMF | ISO 42001 | EU AI Act | HITRUST AI RMF |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Objectives | Emphasizes risk management, ethical development, and trustworthiness of AI systems. | Aims to establish a framework for managing AI risks, and ensuring safe, transparent, and ethical AI practices. | The EU AI Act aims to regulate AI across the EU by setting standards for safety, transparency, and accountability. | HITRUST AI RMF aims to integrate AI risk management with the existing HITRUST CSF standards for a thorough approach. |
| Focus | Helps in handling AI risks and promotes ethical AI development across various sectors. | Guides companies in fulfilling their AI-related roles responsibly. | Centers on establishing legal requirements for AI systems, focusing on high-risk applications, and ensuring safety and transparency. | HITRUST AI RMF links AI risk management with the HITRUST CSF, emphasizing a unified approach to security and compliance. |
| Core of the Framework | Includes Govern, Map, Measure, and Manage functions to foster a risk-aware culture. | Centers around risk assessment and management. | Categorizes AI systems by risk level, setting out specific obligations and requirements based on these categories. | It integrates AI risk management within the broader HITRUST CSF, focusing on comprehensive risk assessment and mitigation. |
| Compliance Process | Requires familiarizing with the framework, assessing practices, identifying risks, developing strategies, implementing controls, and continuous monitoring of systems. | Involves evaluating AI practices, creating a compliance plan, conducting risk assessments, implementing measures, addressing gaps, and preparing for certification audits. | Requires compliance with various obligations depending on the AI system’s risk category, including risk assessments, documentation, and reporting. | With HITRUST, you align your AI practices with the CSF, conduct risk assessments, put controls in place, and work towards HITRUST certification. |
| Impact on Service Organization | Provides specific outcomes and actions to manage AI risks effectively. | Emphasizes compliance with data protection laws and setting up security measures for competitive advantage | Aims to standardize AI practices across the EU, affecting how organizations design, develop, and deploy AI systems. | HITRUST AI RMF helps you align AI risk management with the HITRUST CSF, boosting your overall security and compliance. |
| Number of Controls | Focuses on four key functions under the “Core” and offers a Generative AI Profile. | Includes 39 Annex A controls covering various aspects of AI management. | Sets out specific requirements and obligations for different risk categories, affecting how organizations manage their AI systems. | HITRUST AI RMF works within the HITRUST CSF framework, which includes a detailed set of controls for managing risks. |
| Application | You can use NIST AI RMF alongside other frameworks to get a well-rounded approach to AI risk management. | Can be applied alongside other frameworks to enhance AI governance and risk management processes. | Applies specifically to AI systems operating within or affecting the EU, aiming for broad regulatory compliance. | HITRUST AI RMF fits into the HITRUST CSF, offering a comprehensive approach to both security and compliance. |
Latest NIST AI RMF news
Impact, Risks, and Examples of AI in Cybersecurity
September 9, 2024
Frequently asked questions
What are the NIST requirements for AI?
The NIST AI RMF outlines requirements for developing and deploying trustworthy AI systems, focusing on reliability, safety, security, transparency, accountability, and fairness. Organizations must also establish governance frameworks to ensure compliance with ethical and regulatory standards for an effective AI risk management.
Which US agency is responsible for the AI risk management framework?
The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), an agency of the U.S. Department of Commerce, is responsible for the AI Risk Management Framework (AI RMF). NIST develops and promotes measurement standards and technology to enhance innovation and industrial competitiveness. The agency collaborates with various stakeholders to ensure the framework’s relevance and applicability across different sectors.
When did NIST release the AI risk management framework?
NIST released the AI Risk Management Framework (AI RMF) on January 26, 2023.
Does NIST AI RMF have a certification?
Currently, the NIST AI RMF does not offer a formal certification. Instead, it serves as a guideline and best practices framework for organizations to align their AI risk management practices with. However, organizations can demonstrate compliance and adherence to the framework through self-assessments, third-party audits, and by implementing the recommended practices.
Who can perform NIST AI assessments?
NIST AI assessments can be performed by qualified internal teams, third-party auditors, or consultants with expertise in AI risk management and the NIST AI RMF. I.S. Partners offers a complete package of services to help organizations implement the AI RMF standards according to their industry requirements.
