Key Takeaways
1. Vendor SOC reports offer insights into a vendor’s control environment, which is crucial for businesses that rely on their services.
2. SOC reports serve multiple purposes, including verifying controls, providing an overview of the product/service, and ensuring compliance with industry standards.
3. IS Partners specializes in assisting companies with scrutinizing vendor SOC reports. Our expert team offers comprehensive support, from conducting risk assessments to performing gap analyses.
How to Analyze Vendor SOC Reports?
Analyzing a vendor SOC report requires careful evaluation of its critical parts, which a professional auditor must conduct.
Understanding their SOC report is essential to keeping your data safe and ensuring your vendors are doing their part. This guide will show you the basic steps to evaluate your vendor’s SOC report so you can understand how it is reviewed.
Evaluate the Provider of the SOC Examination
Reviewing a SOC report involves assessing the provider’s credibility and who performed the examination. Here are key factors to consider:
- Independence and Licensing. Ensure that the report is issued by an independent service auditor, a licensed CPA (Certified Public Accountant), or a CPA firm.
- Experience. Check if the firm has substantial experience in performing SOC reports.
- Expertise. Verify that the firm has expertise in internal controls, IT systems, technology, and relevant credentials such as CPA, CISA (Certified Information Systems Auditor), or CISSP (Certified Information Systems Security Professional).
Check the Cover Page and Auditor’s Opinion Letter
When reviewing a SOC report, examine the cover page and auditor’s opinion letter to gain an initial understanding. Next, ensure that the vendor conducts a risk assessment to determine the appropriate SOC report for your company.
Also, confirm that the report’s scope aligns with the vendor’s services to your service organization. This thorough examination will help you obtain the relevant and accurate information needed to assess the vendor’s controls better.
Inspect the Period of Coverage
Make sure the report’s date matches the timeframe that’s relevant to your operations and any recent changes. Consider any big events or shifts in your business during that time and how they might affect the effectiveness of the controls mentioned in the report.
In addition, see if the coverage period fits your risk management processes; it helps you trust that the information in the SOC report is up-to-date and useful for your needs.
Check the Type of Opinion
Check the type of opinion given by the service auditor, which you can find in their report. This opinion tells you how your vendor performed in their SOC examination.
There are four possible SOC opinions: adverse, disclaimer, qualified, and unqualified. Each one reflects a different outcome of the examination.
If there is no “except for” language, it’s considered an “unmodified opinion,” which is the best outcome. This means your vendor’s system is accurately presented (for SOC 1) or aligned with the description criteria (for SOC 2).
Check for Third-Party References and their Controls
Look for any third-party references, often referred to as subservice organizations, mentioned in the report. Your vendor relies on these companies or services to provide their own.
Make sure these references are relevant to the services your vendor provides to your organization. Also, see if the report indicates whether these third parties are applicable or excluded from the scope of the examination.
Review Significant Changes
Check the “Significant Changes to the System” section in a Type 2 SOC report. This section describes any major changes to the system during the reporting period that might affect the controls in place.
These changes could include adding new services, making acquisitions, or switching cloud service providers. The section should tell you when the change happened and what was different before and after the change.
Other Factors to Consider When Analyzing Vendor SOC Reports
In addition to the mentioned factors in analyzing Vendor SOC reports, organizations must consider other information about the documents and connected vendors.
Here are other aspects to perform when analyzing vendor SOC reports:
- Review Management’s Information: Check if the information provided by your vendor’s management accurately reflects the services offered and understand the control objectives.
- Examine Control Testing Results (Type 2 Reports): Look for deficiencies in the control testing results provided by the service auditor, especially in Type 2 reports.
- Assess Your Company’s Control Structure Requirements: Review Complementary User Entity Controls (CUECs) and User Responsibilities sections to ensure your organization meets the necessary controls and responsibilities outlined in the report.
- Determine if the Report is “Inclusive” or “Carved Out”: Understand whether the report includes testing of subservice organizations’ controls (inclusive) or not (carved out) and how this impacts your vendor’s responsibilities and monitoring of subservice organizations.
Looking for answers about vendor SOC reports and who can help you understand them better? Our team at IS Partners, LLC has you covered! We can answer all your questions about the latest updates from the AICPA’s professional standards.
Purpose of Vendor SOC Reports
A third-party vendor SOC (System and Organization Controls) report indicates whether a vendor’s controls are working well or if there are any issues, especially for type II examinations.
These reports are usually requested by customers who use the vendor’s services to handle important data. They give insights into how the vendor safeguards data confidentiality, integrity, and availability, which is crucial for businesses relying on their services.
Verification of Controls
Vendor SOC reports offer a means to verify that controls have been tested independently. They are your backstage pass to ensure that the security controls your vendor has put in place are not just for show.
This report provides evidence that independent experts have tested these controls, confirming operating effectiveness.
Overview of Product/Service
Beyond simply confirming controls, vendor SOC reports give you an overview of the product or service being utilized by the vendor you’re targeting.
This includes details about the vendor’s infrastructure, processes, and security protocols, allowing organizations to understand better how the vendor operates and how its product or service fits within your organization’s ecosystem.
Assurance of Compliance
SOC reports ensure that the vendor’s controls align with industry standards and regulatory requirements. These reports confirm that the vendor’s controls meet industry standards and regulatory requirements like GDPR, HIPAA, or PCI DSS.
Reviewing these reports means you can trust that your vendor is keeping your data safe and meeting the legal benchmarks.
Risk Assessment
Vendor SOC reports are your go-to tools for evaluating the risks of working with a particular vendor. They look at how well the vendor’s controls protect data security, availability, confidentiality, and integrity.
Who are Vendor SOC Reports for?
Vendor SOC reports are primarily requested by customers or clients of service organizations that handle sensitive data. These reports provide crucial insights into the vendor’s controls and processes so they are operating properly and protecting data confidentiality, integrity, and availability.
Typically, vendors providing critical services, such as cloud storage, payment processing, or IT security, will have SOC reports. However, not all vendors will have these reports. For instance, low-risk vendors like painting companies usually don’t need SOC reports since they don’t handle sensitive data.
However, it’s concerning if a critical vendor cannot provide a current SOC report, as this raises questions about their control environment and overall security posture. In such cases, you should reconsider the relationship with that vendor to ensure data security and regulatory compliance.
Types of Vendor SOC Reports
Vendor SOC reports are categorized into different types based on their objectives. They offer detailed insights into your vendors’ security and control measures. Understanding these reports is paramount for assessing the reliability and integrity of your vendors’ operations.
Below, we describe the different types of vendor SOC reports.
SOC 1
SOC 1 reports are designed for companies that provide services impacting their clients’ internal control over financial reporting. There are two types of SOC 1 reports:
- SOC 1 Type I Report: This report reviews the controls that are in place at a specific point in time.
- SOC 1 Type II Report: This report assesses controls over a selected period of time, offering a more comprehensive view.
Type II reports are often preferable because they evaluate the controls over an extended period. This provides insight into any significant changes in performance during that time, giving a clearer picture of the vendor’s operations.
SOC 2
SOC 2 reports focus on controls related to security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, and privacy. A SOC 2 report is intended for companies that operate, collect, process, transmit, store, organize, maintain, and dispose of information for their customers.
Known as the five Trust Services Criteria, SOC 2 reports evaluate one or more of these categories to ensure vendors have proper controls to protect sensitive information.
Similar to SOC 1 reports, there are two types of SOC 2 reports:
- SOC 2 Type I Report: Reviews controls at a specific point in time.
- SOC 2 Type II Report: Assesses the operational performance of controls over a period of time.
Type II reports are generally preferred as they offer a more detailed evaluation by assessing controls over an extended period and ensuring that your controls are operating effectively.
SOC 3
SOC 3 reports are general-use reports similar to SOC 2 but without a detailed description of the auditor’s testing and results. They are designed to be publicly available and can be shared widely, offering a high-level summary of the vendor’s controls.
SOC for Cybersecurity
This type focuses on an organization’s cybersecurity risk management program.
SOC for Cybersecurity engagements can be performed for any organization, regardless of size or industry, and are not limited to service providers.
SOC for Supply Chain
SOC for Supply Chain is the newest type of SOC report designed to help suppliers and logistics providers validate the effectiveness of their controls and clearly understand the risks present within their supply chains.
How Often Do You Need To Review Vendor SOC Reports?
Deciding how often to review your vendor’s SOC report depends on your organization’s needs. Typically, these reports are issued annually, but some vendors may release them more frequently, such as every six months or every three months.
For vendor management, a SOC report provides insights into how a vendor manages its systems and controls and can be very useful in identifying and/or mitigating the risks associated with a vendor’s services.
Elevate Your Security With Comprehensive SOC Reports
Vendor SOC reports reports serve a dual purpose:
- It offers a comprehensive view of a vendor’s control environment pre-contracting
- Providing ongoing oversight post-engagement.
With a documented review of your vendor’s SOC report, you can track specific changes over time, including exception remediation, significant changes, and system adjustments. If you require assistance in scrutinizing your vendor’s SOC reports, IS Partners is your trusted auditing firm.
With over 20 years of experience in auditing and creating comprehensive reports, our experts can help you discern critical elements in vendor SOC reports.
From conducting risk assessments to performing gap analysis, we offer 100% support. Also, as a leading provider of internal audit services globally, IS Partners conducts on-site and remote SOC audits. Let our seasoned experts guide you toward achieving your business objectives.
Ready to take the next step? Request a quote today to kickstart the process!
.
